Discussion about this post

User's avatar
OverIT's avatar

Dear Editor,

Thank you so much for publishing today’s Op-Ed on The Youth Gender debate sparked by the Release of the Cass Report.

As the parent of an autistic teen who thinks it is possible to change one’s sex, it is always a relief to read something in the mainstream that takes a more circumspect approach on this issue. Someday soon, I hope to see an investigative piece that is not just in the op-ed section which has been the case with the Washington Post and the NY Times.

The piece on the Autistic Trans college kid who wanted to be accepted into the sorority was in the online edition of the WaPo for quite some time, among other articles of a pro trans nature.

Please consider doing an investigative article on WPATH’s influence on the APA, AMA and AAP. Also dig into the release of the WPATH files. They are quite revealing. Interview parents who are struggling. Interview both detransitioners and people who have transitioned, (ideally been transitioned for more than 10 years).

This issue may not affect enough of the population in the more tangible ways but I believe it has affected everyone in the less tangible ways, ie. our speech(how we refer to people, pronouns) , how we think about biology and our sense of reality. It is no trivial matter and it will leave a lasting affect on my kids’ generation for years to come.

Thank you,

Expand full comment
Mark Buchanan's avatar

My words of wisdom submitted to WaPo:

I am a physician with special interest in the evidence behind medical strategies to affirm a trans identity, and have followed the Cass Commission for at least 2 years. Its release is a huge resource for medicine and the broader society as we try to sort out what actually helps gender dysphoric kids. It has been extensively covered in the UK media outlets of all political persuasions. In the US, not so much. I see your editorial, an article in the NYT, and something in the Atlantic, plus not surprisingly in conservative outlets like the NY Post. We need to be hearing much more. Unfortunately, opinions on gender have aligned with political identity in the US. With the Cass Report, the UK is taking the lead in getting politics out of gender care. We need more of that in the US.

The Washington Post took early leadership in covering questioning voices back in 2021 when it published the editorial by Erica Anderson and Laura Edwards-Leeper advocating gender exploratory treatment for gender questioning kids. That was a good start, but you now have an enormous opportunity to inject science into the American debate. I hope you will aggressively share the Cass Report with the American public.

Expand full comment
16 more comments...

No posts